Re: Album Metacritic
Wed Aug 03, 2022 6:00 am
Universally Acclaimed (81-100/100)
- Albums:
Future Nostalgia - Dua Lipa
89
Generally Favorable Reviews (61-80/100)
- Albums:
the way i used to - Kelsea Ballerini
74
midnight feelings - Reece King
73
Free Yourself - Keke Palmer
71
Mixed or Average Reviews (40-60/100)
- Albums:
Teary Eyes - Katy Perry
56
Generally Unfavorable Reviews (20-39/100)
- Albums:
N/A
Overwhelming Dislike (0-19/100)
- Albums:
N/A
Re: Album Metacritic
Wed Aug 03, 2022 6:14 am
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 4
Mixed: 6
Negative: 1
- Critic Reviews:
- The Telegraph (UK) - 85
- Full Review:
Adele has finally released her fourth studio album, her first album in many years, she is known for her lengthy breaks between musical eras and I am significantly pleased with this project. In the past, I have always been highly critical of the Chasing Pavements singer and especially on her albums. Despite Adele's great talents as a vocalist, her albums have always lacked versatility and range. Adele always played it safe with her sounds and has been in dire need of some form of experimentation. Fortunately, "30" showcases that the Someone Like You singer was eager to experiment and advance her discography to new horizons. In the almost 7 minutes of "My Little Love", there is a very sentimental addition to the production, the singer is heard having a conversation with her son, the song is substantially reflective and even though Adele is known to be expressive, this style of production is relatively new to her and she executed it excellently. Her powerful vocals and seamless lyrics enhance the beauty of this track and cement it as one of the best songs of her career, a catalog highlight, and one of the best of the year. Another lengthy song on this album was "I Drink Wine", this song has a piano-driven production with additions of various instruments in the background, Adele's strength is her soulful voice and this song allows her to belt and soar effortlessly, one can feel every emotion from her vocal performance on this track. Despite not being the most experimental song, she definitely has elevated this typical sound and made it into something spectacular and passionate, I can also see this song being used in a soundtrack of a really sad romantic movie because it fits perfectly. "All Night Parking" featuring Errol Garner displays the singer's aim of trying new styles of music. This Sade-inspired track is jazzy and you can envision yourself at a jazz lounge, drinking wine, chatting with your comrades, and vibing to this type of music, it also has hints of Rhythm and Blues, these two styles were skillfully blended and created magnificence. The instrumental interludes on the album add a euphoric and much-needed pause from the lengthy tracks and allow the listeners to prepare themselves for the next song and it closes the album effectively. The choir heavy "Oh My God" is another key highlight of this album sonically. This song's title has a clever double meaning to the actual context of the song and the inclusion of the spiritual elements undoubtedly assists this song in being in the holy trinity of this album. My only issue with this album is that some songs like "Hold On" and "To Be Loved" were unnecessarily long and could have been omitted from the full track list as they did not leave a substantial impact on me, sometimes less is more. Regardless, Adele has definitely stepped up from her last lazy efforts and has produced her most experimental and innovative record to date.
Variety - 72- Full Review:
"She’s back, though pop superstar Adele needs no introduction to the world of music. To call Adele a simple hitmaker is an understatement as she has created some of the biggest and most memorable songs of the last decade. True to tradition in Adele’s career is the big ballad lead single going #1. This was most definitely the case with I Don’t Think About You. A power ballad that shot to the top of the Hot 100. After that taste of the music that was to come, Adele returned from her now traditional long absence with another collection of tear jerkers that and a few surprises that both hit and miss the mark. The album starts off with the song, Strangers By Nature. The song begins with the line “I'll be taking flowers to the cemetery of my heart”. This, alone with the haunting instrumental and ghost-like backing vocals prepares the listener for rest of album. After that intro, the next five tracks show what Adele is truly made of. I Don’t Think About You and Easy On Me, while no different from the lyrical content Adele is known for, are amplified by her strong vocal presence. My Little Love is a six minute ballad in which Adele shares private conversations she had with her son and herself. She does this while being vulnerable with her son, implying that she has a lot to learn. Oh My God, which is the second single from the album, is a beauty of a song with lyrics of being your own woman and putting yourself first. The lyrics plus Adele’s vocal performance makes this a standout track on the album. Sadly, Can I Get It and Didn’t I are some of the weaker songs on the album. Honestly, no amount of vocal acrobatics can save them. The album does pick around I Drink Wine. And continues along that path. Another stand out song is the powerful and emotionally devastating song “To Be Loved”. Though the instrumental is simple piano, the lyrics paired with Adele’s vocal delivery makes this a stand track, not only on the album but in her entire discography. The penultimate track, “Love Is Game” along with the final track, “Endless Journey” are a fitting end to the album. Though the album has a few hiccups which hurt the overall cohesiveness of the album, 30 is a great, and sometimes heart-wrenching album, that delivers some of Adele’s best material so far in her career.
Standouts: My Little Love, Oh My God, To Be Loved
Duds: Can I Get It, Didn’t I"
Rolling Stone - 71- Full Review:
Adele makes her long awaited comeback with 30, a more jazz and 50s inspired album than her previous work, despite those being her influences back in 19. Known for her slow and mellow music, most of her work consisting of ballads she finally adventures more into more than just ballads and slow songs. It’s a bit more than just another 21 vol 3, even if the argument can be made to be grouped as such, though it reminisces more of 19. Does it earn its runtime?, no is what most people will say but depending on your mood the answer could vary.
“Strangers by Nature” starts off the album and sets the mood, the song sounds like it came out of a 40s melodrama or even Cinderella and nobody would bat an eye. A stylish track that starts off the album pretty well. 2nd track “I Don’t Think About You” which was the first single off the album comes in true Adele fashion as the power ballad that kicked the era, it’s a good song that encapsulates everything about the album albeit a bit safe.
“Easy On Me” is another power ballad that could cause whiplash given the song that comes before it has a completely different message though this one feels like the single that never was. A piano ballad that Adele knows all too well how to do. “My Little Love” is a duet with her son which is a very cute concept though is not perfectly executed and goes #relatable when it goes into the spoken part of it, the violin sounds great but the song could use a little less of the time it was given to get its point across.
Now the real treasure in the album is the “Cry Your Heart Out”, “Oh My God”, “Can I Get It” and “Didn’t I” run slapped in the middle of the album. In “Cry Your Heart Out” Adele finally mixes it up and delivers a song that we haven’t heard from her, the background vocals and the instrumentals along with her deliver what it feels like a classic sound that would have the main singer and the background singers behind her like an old school cartoon or jazz musicians back in the 60s. A breath of fresh air from Adele. “Oh My God” and “Can I Get It” are the radio friendly songs Adele puts on the album and while they’re classic Adele and Max Martin song they are both something that adds a bit of flavour to the album, the former feels like a 2nd single choice and it is one after all Adele just released it as such. And finally “Didn’t I” bass line is incredible and is one of the best deep cuts in her discography, her delivery is on point and the song maybe should’ve been the lead of this whole album despite it’s mood not fitting the theme she’s got going on with the rest of the tracks of the album.
“Titanic Rising” is one of the 3 instrumental interludes in the album, this one is just instrumental. It adds nothing to the album despite being an adventurous thing to do for Adele, it leads into another #relatable song for Adele, “I Drink Wine” feels like the quintessential Adele track, a piano, clean vocals and lyrics that everyone relates to, this one though is 6 minutes long. She pours her heart out and has a nice instrumental to go alongside her. “All Night Parking” is the 2nd interlude, the only one that has vocals alongside it. It stands out as a completely different song in the album, it's not about heartbreak and the instrumentals while very Adele are put to a great use here and they stand out in a good way, one of the better tracks in the second half of the album.
“Hold On” doesn’t earn its 6 minute runtime, a problem with the tracks that have that length. It picks up too late and when it does it takes a different route and never lands what it's trying to do.
“To Be Loved” is what could be called her best track. The only 6 minute track on the album that actually justifies being that long, a song where she justifies her divorce despite not having to do so. She explains how young she was and now has to face herself and the decisions she has made. “Picture Me Better” and “Love Is A Game” feel like complementary songs, the latter picks up where the former begins and create a nice run of tracks.
“Nearer to Thee” the final instrumental interlude closes the album though it feels unnecessary given how “Love Is a Game” ends, it also feels like it should be at the half of the album rather than at the end
Adele comes back with 30 which details her experience with divorce and the relationships involved, making it the most personal album in her career which is saying something for the person that put out 21 and 25, though neither of those explore the pain one can cause theior close ones and try to learn to love again. And while it feels pretty Adele she decides to break her usual formula a bit and delivers a better album than 25.
Entertainment Weekly - 69- Full Review:
As one of the highlight artists of the 2010s, Adele has always been an artist that is universally loved, now returning with her fourth studio album and her first album since the release of her 2015 studio album 25 eight years prior, 30 centers on Adele's divorce, motherhood, fame, heartache, acceptance, hope, and inner healing. the album opens up with “Strangers by Nature,” an introduction to the album which is produced by the executive producer of the album Greg Kurstin and solely written by Adele herself as is the rest of the album, Seems to be inspired by the songs of Judy Garland and Disney-like production, Adele talks her past relationships in a dramatic manner despite the floating relaxing sensation you get from the production (“I’ll be taking flowers to the cemetery of my heart”). follows it is I Don't Think About you which is shaping up to be one of the most successful songs released this year, Then comes Easy on Me, a piano ballad where Adele asks God and her own infant son to go easy on her during those tough times she was going through during all those years. one of the biggest highlights of the album is Oh My God, reminds me of the Adele we always knew and loved, a very Rolling In The Deep-esque song with a powerful punching chorus, and showing Adele's vocal prowess over a very simple yet effective production by Greg Kurstin. furthermore down the tracklist "I Drink Wine" an Elton John-esque track with gospel tones, the six-minute track is basically a soundtrack to Adele's own life, the first verse being about her childhood and later on talks about how she hopes to "learn to get over myself" ending the track with a bizarre voice memo. on Love is a Game, one of the final tracks on the album, that only seems to be influenced and a nod to Amy Winehouse's "Love is A Losing Game", heavily featuring strings and increasingly prominent call-and-response backing vocals with herself as we near the climax of the song Adele makes peace with her old self and closes a chapter of her life "God only knows how I’ve cried I can’t take another defeat A next time would be the ending of me". Although 30 is at times slow-paced and the rawest of the records she’s made to date, it also manages to be her most fun record to date.
The Observer (UK) - 60- Full Review:
Adele’s fourth studio album 30 shows the artist at her most vulnerable and alive to her own feelings, but her ambitious take on expressing her guilt comes at a certain cost. Reuniting with Grammy-award winning producer Greg Kurstin, Adkins produces her most raw and personal album. One of the best displays of this vulnerability is on “My Little Love”, which features private snippets of Adele and her son Angelo as they adjust to the divorce. This shows a new side of Adele that fans haven’t seen yet and is borderline uncomfortable to listen to. “My Little Love” is a journey which sums up this record pretty well, tucked at the end is Adele’s version of rock bottom, a raw voice note where she admits that, for the first time in years, she feels really and truly lonely. Adele is at her strongest on this record on the grounding piano ballad “Easy On Me” which showcases the expressive singer’s second-to-none tone as well as her excellent songwriting. On this song, Adele asks for grace from herself, the lord, and her son Angelo. Adele’s guilt from the divorce yields the record’s best material on tracks like this. Another strong point on the record is the opener “Strangers by Nature”, richly produced by Kurstin. We hear Adele mourn her past relationships in a dramatic and camp manner, complied with Disney like strings and an excellent opening line (“I’ll be taking flowers to the cemetery of my heart”) Despite the depression, we hear the playful song “Cry Your Heart Out” where there are modulated Motown-style background vocals bouncing off Adele’s rich tone. Unfortunately, this record is at its lowest point when Adele is out of her comfort zone on tracks like “Can I Get It” and “Didn’t I”, with the latter being the worst song of her career. These two songs are incredibly out-of-place on this record and sound like something that would feature on a Ella Henderson album. Not only is the corny whistling and aged production out-of-place on the album, but it almost ruins the past few tracks. Thankfully the album gets back on course with “I Drink Wine”, one of the highlights on the album. This song features strong gospel undertones and vivid vocals.(“I hope I learn to get over myself,” ) she belts in the chorus, a hint of grit in her low notes. As we move into the final third of the record, we listen to some of the strongest work on the album including the incredible “To Be Loved”. The 6-minute ballad aims to show what happens when you willingly walk off the cliff and live to tell about it. “Picture Me Better” is another highlight featuring masterful songwriting, although the engineering does sound out-of-place compared to the rest of the tracks. Overall, 30 is Adele’s most vulnerable record and showcases her masterful vocal ability and songwriting, but the experimental moments on the record (“Can I Get It”, “Didn’t I”) fail to impress and almost diminishes the impact that a listener gets when listening to the stronger tracks.
Pitchfork - 51- Full Review:
Adele is perhaps one of the biggest pop stars our generation will ever see and naturally her comeback album after a 6 year hiatus was accompanied by a lot of hype and fanfare and while "30" might appeal to the casual listener simply in search for some playlist-fodder, more demanding listeners are sure to be disappointed.
On "30" Adele has seemingly exhausted all of her lyrical talents. Despite being billed as her most personal album to date, outside of a few personal details thrown into the mix it might as well have been written by a writing camp. Her early singer-songwriter days were already over on "25" but this album is for all those who still had any doubts. All the highlights of the album succeed purely due to Adele's vocal performances and the odd catchy melody. "I Drink Wine" and "Hold On" are prime examples. "To Be Loved" manages to be one of her most emotionally potent ballads of her career. Even if thematically it is just a retread of "Easy On Me", her raw and explosive vocals put it leagues above the latter track.
Every single track is produced by Greg Kurstin, which is certainly a strange choice as someone of Adele's stature could certainly have all the world's best producers at a snap of her fingers. Kurstin can certainly put together a good ballad or two but complex compositions have never been his strength and it's painfully obvious on this album. Adele's pitched up, multilayered vocals on "Cry Your Heart Out" are otitis-inducing, while "Oh My God" could be an Imagine Dragons reject. "My Little Love" sounds great in theory yet it ends up excruciatingly long, washed-out and soulless.
Strange is also the album's sequencing. Both interludes are unnecessary and the final one in particular devalues the catharsis on "Love Is A Game", even though when looking at the project as a whole that catharsis seems disingenuous and unearned as on "I Don't Think About You" Adele already seems completely healed and over the break up.
Once hailed as "the next Amy Whinehouse", Adele does an utter disservice to that title. "30" is devoid of the soul aspect of her pop/soul genre and proves there's more to being a great artist than powerful vocals. Even the few moments of brilliance pale in comparison to the best tracks on "21" and whether that album was just lightning in a bottle or Adele has simply lost her songwriting talents remains a mystery.
Paste Magazine - 45- Full Review:
Adele’s 30 seems to be a return to form for the singer. She has built her career on big vocals and sweeping ballads and this album is full of them. On the second track and lead single, ‘I Don’t Think About You’, she sings about moving on with her life after her divorce and on ‘My Little Love’ she expresses her love for her son. However, both of these songs lack the emotional punch of her past work. Her vocals are shrill, the songs are too long, and interrupted by talking that doesn’t seem to further the song’s message. It’s not all duds though, on album highlights ‘Didn’t I’ and ‘All Night Parking Interlude’ she captures a sound that is both current and unique to her. The first track is evocative of Kelly Clarkson’s stellar album ‘Meaning of Life.’ It’s a shame that that sound wasn’t explored more here. The track ‘Hold On’ which takes place towards the middle of the album encapsulates the issues and strengths of this album. It begins as a piano ballad and gradually builds to a fantastic climax in the last two minutes. Unfortunately, Adele never does anything to justify the extent of time it takes to bridge the six minute gap. This album does have other moments of brightness such as the seamless transition from ‘Picture Me Better’ into ‘To Be Loved’ and the non-autotuned potion of ‘Cry Your Heart Out.’ It’s just hard to parse out these moments from the muddled and slow vibes on the rest of the album.
In an interview supporting her previous album, 25, she expressed that it would be her last album named after her age. However she seems to have retracted that and gone ahead with the title 30. I was confused on why she decided to call it that. Did she want to continue the age trend? Did she feel like this album expressed the wisdom that comes with age? Was it a numerical representation of how many seconds until I wanted to turn every song off? Then it dawned on me; Adele has made it a point to name her albums after the age she wrote them, to define them by what she’s learned, what she’s done, what she’s lost. Her fourth full length studio album seems to follow that pattern. After listening you realize she’s learned how to be a mother, she’s drunk a lot of wine, and she’s lost the ability to make enjoyable music.
New Musical Express (NME) - 45- Full Review:
Like with most Adele releases, they always draw immense hype, after all, she IS the “queen of ballads”. But with this release specifically there was some expetaations put onto her. Will she finally do something not a sappy piano ballad about a breakup? Will she do something more upbeat? Will she write something that’s not a breakup song? The short answer is no.
After being absent for many many years, people were excited and curious about the next chapter of Adele’s life, especially after making headlines about the divorce with her husband Simon Konecki. After hearing more about the divorce, it caused more of a drive to hear what Adele has to say.
The album begins with “Strangers by Nature” and track reminiscent of an old Judy Garland and a spine-tingling orchestra that brings you back to the world of theater in the 60s. With this opener, you’re already strapped in a wild ride and you follow Adele’s journey and transformation following her divorce and life raising a small child who you would believe to be clueless in all of this. Strangers offers an amazing start to the album that keeps you hooked in on what she will say next. Unfortunately, it goes downhill after track 1, which is not a good sign. The second song being the lead single “I Don’t Think About You” is easily a contender for worst tracks of the year. The grating and annoying chorus and the most basic lyrics that can ever be written, the fact that this was made the single instead of the steller beginning track proves the Capitol Records deserves to be defunked. Ignoring that one, the album shortly picks itself back up with the catchy and singable tune “Easy on Me”. Once again, the lyrics don’t take much to analyze or think too closely about, but what makes this track a highlight is most definitely Adkins’ vocal style and performance. “My Little Love” is unfortunately the last redeeming track off the album that offers any sort of substance or anything “good” about the album. But with that track, it can be considered as the centerpiece to the album. The lengthy 6 minute ballad features real audio recordings of a conversation between Adkins and her son Angelo as Adkins attempts to explain the divorce and what that means as well as how Adkins is felling in that moment. Obviously, a kid can only understand so much, so it was both endearing but also difficult to hear.
After this song, the album goes down another steep hill, but doesnt try to pick itself back up. It’s not until the track “Picture Me Better” where you can see and hear a transformation within Adele. An album full of Picture Me Better’s wouldve made this listening experience a lot better. But instead, we got another set of dragged piano ballads that almost leaves you wanting to fall asleep. There is nothing redeeming about this album and it gives nothing that we haven’t seen Adele do for the past three albums already.
At a staggering runtime of over one-hour you would think Adele would want to do something interesting to keep your attention halfway through, but instead gave songs that made it difficult to stay awake.
Consequence of Sound - 40- Full Review:
On her fourth studio album ‘30’, Adele doesn’t manage to overcome the ‘rinse & repeat’ that is often used to describe her discography. Even though there are a few attempts at pushing past her usual piano-driven sonical boundaries (on the one hand, more upbeat songs like “Can I Get It” or “Didn’t I” - on the other, more theatrical, grand efforts like “Strangers By Nature” or “Solitude”), and despite the fact one could say there are hints of experimentation that weren’t as present in her previous efforts, the overall result remains a safe choice for an established artist like her and one of the most distinct vocalists of our generation.
Carried by the chart-topping smash “I Don’t Think About You” and its follow-up “Oh My God”, the record showcases signature Adele lyricism and instrumentals. Still nostalgic, still heart-wrenching, now stained by the aftermath of the singer’s highly publicized divorce, thematically ‘30’ milks the break-up anthem lane the English songstress feels so comfortable in. It still feels like a classic Adele album, in the sense that it serves all your spring heartbreak needs and more.
The album’s downfall is mainly carried by its length. There are way too many songs that do not enhance the listening experience. They actually hinder it. There is no need for multiple instrumental interludes in an album like this. Additionally, the repetition of topics and themes makes it feel even longer. The project feels like it drags on forever as a result. By the time you reach the closing track, you’ve forgotten about the highlights of the album (which get lost around the middle of the album, some being “Easy On Me”, “I Drink Wine”, and possibly the crown jewel “To Be Loved”, which is individually affected by the excessive length issue, with a runtime of almost seven minutes).
If you were expecting a direction shift, you may be disappointed by this album. One can’t help but feel like this won’t age as well as some of her older efforts. And that is because it does not feel like an album that has been over half a decade in the making. If we were to compare her age-title saga with a movie franchise, ‘30’ would be known as the filler one. Whether that means it will remembered as her worst, most uninspired effort, or the grounds for a career revival moment with her upcoming projects, is yet to be clear.
The New York Times - 40- Full Review:
Adele is no stranger when it comes to ballads. Her past 3 albums main drive was those type of songs, which majority focused on her journey with heartbreak. After nearly a decade of no new music, she returns with a new album, but does it really show that she needed that much length for a break? Does it really show her growth after that much time away? That is where the problem starts.
Adele started the era with the lead single ‘I Don’t Think About You’, which isn’t exactly a bad song, but when she has this much high status, it is time to bring us something NEW. The song delivers what you would expect from her, outstanding performance vocally, but that’s about it. It is a redundant break up song and if you told me it was part of 21 or 25, I wouldn’t tell the difference. Adele then delivers something different, the second single off this album, ‘Oh My God’, which launched alongside the album release and is more uplifting sonically. Contrary to the Metacritic score, it would've been more interesting to see Adele dive into this type of sound as it would’ve been different than her past discography.
Diving into each song one by one shouldn’t be difficult to do however when almost all tracks are similar sounding and have the same type of story, it’s tricky. Songs like My Little Love, I Drink Wine and Love is a Game would’ve been more powerful if they weren’t dragged down by the duration, which are around 6 minutes each. My Little Love particularly could’ve removed all the talking bits and could've been a contender for one of her best songs ever if so. Some parts of the tracklist are wonky, specifically ‘Didn’t I’ which is like an upbeat dated radio candy of the 2014 era clashing onto ‘Solitude’, an instrumental cinematic sounding interlude, which feels like Adele slapped it on solely to meet Grammy eligibility. Not to mention ‘Love is a Game’ feeling like a powerful closer, like you are getting up from your seat at the movie theatre watching the credits roll…. but then ‘Endless Journey’ comes on and ruins the entire flow.
Countless of duds scatter around the album, including ‘Easy on Me’ which, again, is like an outtake of 21 or 25. ‘Didn’t I’ and ‘Can I Get It’ feel like Adele is out of touch and didn’t have a phone all this time, that sound was left almost a decade ago for a reason. ‘Hold On’, ‘Picture Me Better’ and ‘To Be Loved’ are perfect for when you cannot sleep at night. But 30 also contains strong material like ‘Cry Your Heart Out’, ‘Oh My God’, ‘All Night Parking’ and songs like ‘My Little Love’ and ‘Love is a Game’ are great as well, but cannot be listed them with the others because they are longer than needed.
With the world anticipating her return for so long, Adele should’ve came back with a stronger album that dives into a sound that she had not touched in the past. Instead it seems like we'll be getting more of the 21 saga for the rest of our lives.
The Guardian - 35- Full Review:
Nearly eight years have gone by since Adele’s last studio album 25, and in that time, not only the world, but the industry has changed a lot. Streaming became the dominant way to consume music, album promotional cycles have been cut in half, and the general public has a smaller attention span than ever before. Therefore, it makes sense to ask, can the once massively influential Adele adapt to these changes and continue leading the music industry? “I Don’t Think About You”, released at the start of the year as the lead single to her new record 30, might have answered that question commercially, but the record itself tells a very different answer sonically.
At its root, 30 is a regressive progression in Adele’s career. Throughout the album, she delves deep into new musical landscapes, yet somehow manages to cling onto her, at this point, extremely fatiguing expected sound. The issue is, as Adele is entering these new musical landscapes, she is dragging along with her the worst aspects of her musical output. These aspects have been with her since her debut on 19, but have always been able to be ignored, up until their main-stage moment on 30. This is best seen on tracks such as “My Little Love” or “Cry Your Heart Out”. On the former, she attempts to artistically include voice notes from her personal life, but just like her writing, they feel extremely formulaic, giving their addition to the album no meaning. It is as if you can just tell she knew all along these “private recordings” were making the album. Other times on the album, she is just flat out giving the same-old, same-old. The 1-2 punch of “I Don’t Think About You” and “Easy On Me” add no favors to the record as both songs are painfully basic, sounding like every Adele song we have ever heard before. Then there’s her featuring two completely instrumental tracks on the album, “Solitude” and “Endless Journey”. Instrumental songs at their best can serve as a beautiful addition to the album, but at their worst be completely unneeded. These 2 songs fall into the latter. Both are extremely out of place on the album, and “Endless Journey” is extremely criminal with how it completely destroys the genius fade-out outro of “Love Is A Game”, the best track on the album.
Overall, 30 is a steep fall from grace for Adele. It is a sign that what might have worked brilliantly for her back in the early tens on 21, single-handedly ending the dance-pop epidemic, is not working a decade later. One should hope she does not go on another jarringly long hiatus, as the output may somehow come out even worse.
Re: Album Metacritic
Tue Aug 09, 2022 4:19 pm
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 7
Mixed: 2
Negative: 0
- Critic Reviews:
- The Telegraph (UK) - 88
- Full Review:
After eight long-awaited years, Miguel released his fourth studio album titled "Leisure", embracing more psychedelic funk and pop attributes while his R&B roots remain present at all times. "Pineapple Skies" gradually uplifts our emotions with its poppy upbeat tempo. Miguel's pen is on a continuous polarizing rollercoaster in this track. Once you see how many people it took to write this, all the dots seem to connect. "Sky Walker" features the up-and-coming star, Jack Harlow. usually mediocre, Miguel has brought out his best talents on the song (Lucky for us, he is only in it for 30 seconds). I can certainly voice my opinion that this will be the cult classic that we'll all be playing at our late-night parties. Our favorite track off the album is the elegant track "CPR". Although lyrically it seems like your everyday love song of a man telling a woman how much he is in love with her, we instead have fallen in love with the production throughout the entire duration. You embark on a journey through serenity. You're in a sanctuary musically and we will be staying for as long as we want. It Is not quite often that Miguel embraces his Latin side in his music, but in "Caramelo Duro" we are blessed with gentle and tranquil tones while he is charmingly singing in Spanish. Starting the song in English he smoothly transitions into his Spanish dialect. The repeated lyrics are the secret ingredient that enriches the caliber of this song, and it seems that we can give a hefty thanks to Kali Uchis, who helped Miguel compose it. Finally onto the lead single that started all of our journeys, "Come Through & Chill" depicts of a past "lover" who has caught the attention of Miguel, his intentions are candid once you get to the post-chorus. That didn't stop our enjoyment of the lustful track, sometimes you got to think about yourself and do what was right for you at the time. Miguel has created such a sexy body of work, that it seems to be his mission statement whenever he drops the lead single. From the poppy-funk songs that bring the happiness out of your system ("Pineapple Skies", "I Told You So") to the classic smooth R&B songs that bring you to a state of mellowness ("CPR", "Come Through & Chill", "Gentlemen), Miguel has truly given us a bright and beautiful jewel after all these years. Miguel made his mark as a staple of R&B music.
Variety - 87- Full Review:
The Adorn singer has finally released his latest album. Miguel is known to be one of the best voices in male R&B, his vocal range is outstanding and he is often commended for being one of the few who can compete with the greats vocally, along with his counterpart, Frank Ocean. "Leisure" is R&B at it's core but I would describe this album as progressive R&B as the singer plays with various sounds and instruments throughout the album which completes the package. The album opens with "Criminal" which takes the listener on a smooth and easy listen, the melody is quite catchy and it's a simple song to get into, Miguel's voice sounds stellar as per usual and the collaborator on this record, Rick Ross adds a much needed change in tone to break the monotony of the track, "Criminal" is far from my favourite song on this album but it's definitely a solid track and I understand why the singer chose to lead the album with this. The second song "Pineapple Skies" showcases the singer's strength, his instrument. Miguel's powerful vocals are the focal point, he begins the song with a soulful note and continues to belt and flex his voice throughout the song, his use of chest voice and falsetto is notable and definitely sets him apart from the whisper singers in the pop, r&b and music world in general. This song has a similar melody to the classic 'Sexual Healing' by Marvin Gaye and this makes sense as Miguel oozes sex appeal similar to Marvin and sees him as a musical inspiration. The third song is my favourite, "Sky Walker" is a discography highlight. This song is skillfully produced by Miguel himself and Happy Perez and it feels like the perfect song for the summer. I think his intention with this song was making a relatable song for friends to create memories, the lyrical content of the song is one of joy, bliss and freedom, he sings about marijuana, partying, having fun and living in the moment. This song deserved to be the lead single of this album because it has that effortless feel and takes you to the dancefloor or to vibe with your loved ones, it's the perfect package. "Wolf" is another highlight on this album because it shows the singer's aggressive side, he sings the song in a more commanding and dominant tone and it's fitting by the title. "Told You So" would be perfect for pop radio and showcases the singer's versatility. "Caramel Duro" is also another song that could be a single, it's beyond ear candy and showcases the singer's culture, Kali Uchis is also excellent on this track and I can definitely see this song becoming a major hit in the Spanish and English speaking community, it has that crossover appeal, in stan culture language, it's a 'bop'. Miguel's voice is pure sex and this is displayed on "Come Through and Chill", another brilliant track on this album, it's R&B at its finest form and can definitely do well on Rhythm and Urban Radio. The song's lyrics are filled with relatable lines and I can already picture a steamy music video for this gem. 'These Arms' is the perfect closer to this album and the vocals are at the spotlight. Overall, this album was well tailored and is undoubtedly amazing.
Rolling Stone - 83- Full Review:
Miguel returns with his 4th studio album ‘Leisure’ after his last release was nearly a decade ago. His past albums had a more sensual and dark vibe to them, however he returns with a breezy, feel good vibe (for the most part), which is perfect since summer is approaching us soon. With maybe some of his hest vocal performances yet, catchy melodies throughout and strong presences of instruments like guitars, Miguel might’ve crafted his best album yet.
The album starts off with ‘Criminal’ which features Lil Baby, the song gives you that gloominess vibe Miguel fans often crave, all while introducing new sets of instruments we haven’t really heard in his music before. Next track is ‘Pineapple Skies’ which has strong hit potential and is one of the songs that brings the albums energy all together. ‘Sky Walker’, featuring Jack Harlow is yet another song with hit potential and brings out Miguel’s playful and comedic side that his fans aren’t really used to seeing. ‘Wolf’ is a decent song but isn’t as noticeable as the other ones. The album’s next single, ‘Told You So’ is a great choice as it is one of those songs that ties the album together it has ear worm worthy melodies throughout. ‘Caramelo Duro’ punches you with it’s bassline and features a catchy Spanish chorus. It is the best song on the album and it would be amazing to see Miguel craft an album with this type of sound in the future. The album then slows down with the last 3 songs. ‘Come Through and Chill’, the album’s lead single brings back that sensual vibe that older Miguel fans would appreciate.
The album is quite strong overall, however it does have it’s weak links. s‘CPR’, ‘Gentleman’ and ‘These Arms’ don’t really go together with the other songs off the album and come off as cheesy at times. ‘Anointed’ isn’t a bad song, but it is also quite forgettable compared to the highlights of the album and could’ve been replaced with a more uplifting song and instead of stopping the strong punches the songs next to it were giving.
Overall, if this album doesn’t want to make you grab your sunglasses, put your car top down and go far on a road trip then you are doing something wrong. Hopefully some of the highlights become singles in the future and that we can see Miguel’s future album continue this type of vibe, which demonstrated a strong start for something he hasn’t done before.
Entertainment Weekly - 79- Full Review:
- Miguel released his new album “Leisure” and proves his place as an r&b powerhouse. Psychedelia and guitars at the front encompass the sound of this new album. His songwriting abilities have never been sharper than they’ve been on this project. The sublime production and the perfectly laid lyrics make this album a really great listening experience.
Opener “Criminal” features Rick Ross and begins the journey that “Leisure” is. The drums and the guitar riffs alongside Miguel's vocals make this great and then Rick Ross joins and the track roars more life into it. Miguel’s vocals on the outro set perfectly the rest of the album.
“Pineapple Skies” is largely the highlight of the album, the bassline brings a lot into the track mixed with the synths and Miguel’s vocals really make this one of the best tracks on the album. A song that screams enjoyment and its lyrics combined with the instrumentals just make this match perfectly.
“Sky Walker” features Travis Scott and continues greatly on where “Pineapple Skies” left off. The constant synth alongside Miguel’s and Scott’s combined vocals make the song great to listen to. Lyrics are more repetitive than they’ve been so far but it never takes away from the song itself.
“CPR” is another highlight on the album. An easy listen and a song that can easily play at the last leg of a house party where everyone is too hazy to be going crazy. A song that fits the album perfectly.
“Wolf” featuring Quin is a rock infused track and its instrumentals fit like a glove. The vocal layering is the best part of the track. Miguel's vocals pop up amazingly in this track, it the transition between this and the next track is pretty great.
“Gentleman's” instrumentals are fluid, the drums and synths work perfectly together and the vocals are pretty flawless. The synthesizer voice in the outro gives the track a punch to leave a good impression.
“Told You So” and “Caramelo Duro” work in syntony. The former bass’ and drums in the background mixed with the electric guitar make the track encapsulate the whole of what Miguel is trying to do on the album. Meanwhile “Caramelo Duro” which features Kali Uchis in the background vocals is a spanglish track where Miguel fuses the production of his album with his latin roots and makes something that stand out among the 11 album tracks.
“Come Through and Chill” Miguel’s lead single was the introduction to the album and it's a great introduction to what the album is expected to sound like. The electric guitar, its drums and background production are at its best and it's not a wonder why it was chosen as the lead.
“Anointed” the penultimate track on the album in which its synth embraces more the psychedelia Miguel has got going in the album and makes the track roar to life when it begins to pick up during the choruses.
The closer “These Arms” ends the album on a more sweet and romantic tone. The honey like production and its lyrics make it an interesting closer to the album but nonetheless its a great closer and the vocals and harmonies work beautifully.
Miguel’s “Leisure” takes what he has done in the past and amps it up to be at its best. A great release from a great artist.
The Observer (UK) - 75- Full Review:
On his latest full-length album, Miguel delivers the sultry R&B he’s become known for with a little summer flair added in. As the title, Leisure, would suggest, the songs are laid back jams perfect for a night in with your partner or watching sunsets on the beach. The albums first three tracks are a masterclass in Miguel’s artistry and instantly capture the listener. However, the album loses a little steam once it hits the slower tracks in the middle. ‘CPR’ and ‘Gentleman’ both lack anything memorable to push them over the edge and while the track ‘Wolf’ is a very interesting song it feels a bit muddled sandwiched between the two. The next song is the album’s fantastic second single ‘Told You So.’ The funky track was an instant hit with critics upon its release and it remains a highlight here. It flows perfectly into the next track, ‘Caramelo Duro’ which is the best song on the record. The title, which translates to Hard Candy, uses candy metaphors to describe the relationship between Miguel and his lover. While it would be easy for a song like this to feel cheesy and forced the name drops of candy brands like Sour Patch and Starburst never feel forced. He flows effortlessly between the English and Spanish on this sign and delivers one of the best songs of the year so far. After this comes one of the albums weakest points which ironically was the album’s lead single. ‘Come Through and Chill’ is a monotonous mess of a song. It goes nowhere, feels way longer than it is, and leaves the listener feeling a bit fatigued. It’s a wonder this song made it out of the studio, let alone out of the boardroom as the lead single. The next two tracks are an improvement but do nothing to bring back the momentum the album had beforehand. Ultimately, this is a decently strong album. It feels like Miguel made what he wanted to make and succeeded in it but it’s a bit jarring for listeners. One would wish he hadn’t fallen into the biggest pitfall of making a chill/leisurely album which is songs that don’t go anywhere and overstay their welcome. The sound of songs like Criminal, Caramelo Duro, and Sky Walker does have legs though and Miguel should continue to explore that lane because they’re some of the best songs he’s ever made.
Pitchfork - 70- Full Review:
The R&B Prince returns with the evolution of himself. With Leisure, Pimentel offers us his signature smooth and sultry vocals that leave every listener tuned in and prove he’s unique as they come regarding the R&B style.
The album begins with “Criminal” a track that features his buttery soft vocals in the forefront, with a percussive production style that pulls from old-school hip hop. Based on track one, a feel and image can already be made with what “Leisure” will provide. “Pineapple Skies” showcases the dance and groovy side of Miguel, a sound that he has yet been able to show compared to his past albums and releases. And one should compliment this sound on him as he sounds the best and most confident as ever. The next track “Sky Walker” is where we enter the “dud” territory. The track alone is fine, but the issue is that it drags for way too long with no to offer after the two-minute mark. His vocals in the song are not much to point out either. Luckily, Pimentel can redeem himself with “CPR”, a track that brings you back to the 90s when R&B was ruling the charts. In “Wolf”, Miguel takes a different approach that listeners are used to hearing him, this time belting his heart and soul out on a doo-wop type production but moderinzing the sound to what fits him best, and projecting an empowering attempt.
All in all, what Miguel does with his album is all to his strengths. What enlightening about it is that he is not trying to risks for the sake or notoriety and acclaim, he is doing what he does best. There is nothing Pimentel could have done differently with this album in order to get his point across. This album features nothing but soothing R&B jams that can be turned on at anytime of day, and songs that will put a smile on your face.
This album shines Miguel in the best way possible. He brings us in out feels, but can also make us bust a move a minute after. This is a magnificent effort from Miguel, as he has finally found himself and his sound, and makes us curious and excited for what he has to offer in the future. Miguel has  mastered his own vibes and used his strength to make it work, and it did!
Paste Magazine - 65- Full Review:
Miguel’s fourth studio album ‘Leisure’ comes almost eight years after it’s predecessor. Presented with a universe-themed cover, and assisted by high-profile collaborators Lil Baby and Jack Harlow, the album capitalizes on what Miguel is basically an expert at at this point: ad-lib driven melodies and sultry lyrics that make for a perfect bite of modern R&B.
The album opens with “Criminal”, “Pineapple Skies” and “Sky Walker”. The first and third of which feature, respectively, the aforementioned chart-toppers. And are therefore evidently more hip-hop infused than the second. We then cut to “CPR”, which is the most toned down song so far, with lyrics that exploit the metaphor of a lover performing resuscitation on the singer’s heart. Strings make a comeback soon after with “Wolf”, a song where Miguel’s musical influences are most present. One can’t help but feel the album takes a 50 Shades of Grey turn at this point. Which isn’t entirely bad, but isn’t precisely a great thing either. Luckily, we are pulled right back in with “Gentleman”, a song with minimal instrumentation but exquisite falsetto vocals from Miguel. Certainly one of the album’s highlights and potentially the song that best showcases his talents thus far. It is followed by the album's dazzling second single “Told You So” and “Caramelo Duro”, which smoothly transition into each other and bring back the upbeat vibes of the beginning of the album. The latter, which is definitely influenced by Miguel’s Mexican roots, is a hit waiting to happen on latin-american dancefloors. The album’s lead single “Come Through And Chill”, which peaked at #24 on the Billboard Hot 100, comes next. Comparatively it isn’t a strong of an effort as the previous tracks, and feels a little monotonous after the vocal gymnastics we’re used to by this point. The production isn’t that impressive either, which leaves us wondering what exactly made this song the opening act for ‘Leisure’. Certainly the weakest cut on this album. However, the closing tracks, “Anointed” and “These Arms” make a good job at cleaning up the mess their predecessor makes.
Overall, ‘Leisure’ feels like an album where Miguel has been able to explore his capabilities as an artist. For the most part it is an inspired record that capitalizes on the singer’s background and talents. It has a few slips, a few skip-worthy moments that sadly hinder this from being a career-highlight project. Nevertheless, the highs on the tracklist as well as the unique, rare vocals from him, especially for a male artist, make it worth a listen.
New Musical Express (NME) - 60- Full Review:
Miguel’s fourth studio album ‘Leisure’ comes almost eight years after it’s predecessor. Presented with a universe-themed cover, and assisted by high-profile collaborators Lil Baby and Jack Harlow, the album capitalizes on what Miguel is basically an expert at at this point: ad-lib driven melodies and sultry lyrics that make for a perfect bite of modern R&B.
The album opens with “Criminal”, “Pineapple Skies” and “Sky Walker”. The first and third of which feature, respectively, the aforementioned chart-toppers. And are therefore evidently more hip-hop infused than the second. We then cut to “CPR”, which is the most toned down song so far, with lyrics that exploit the metaphor of a lover performing resuscitation on the singer’s heart. Strings make a comeback soon after with “Wolf”, a song where Miguel’s musical influences are most present. One can’t help but feel the album takes a 50 Shades of Grey turn at this point. Which isn’t entirely bad, but isn’t precisely a great thing either. Luckily, we are pulled right back in with “Gentleman”, a song with minimal instrumentation but exquisite falsetto vocals from Miguel. Certainly one of the album’s highlights and potentially the song that best showcases his talents thus far. It is followed by the album's dazzling second single “Told You So” and “Caramelo Duro”, which smoothly transition into each other and bring back the upbeat vibes of the beginning of the album. The latter, which is definitely influenced by Miguel’s Mexican roots, is a hit waiting to happen on latin-american dancefloors. The album’s lead single “Come Through And Chill”, which peaked at #24 on the Billboard Hot 100, comes next. Comparatively it isn’t a strong of an effort as the previous tracks, and feels a little monotonous after the vocal gymnastics we’re used to by this point. The production isn’t that impressive either, which leaves us wondering what exactly made this song the opening act for ‘Leisure’. Certainly the weakest cut on this album. However, the closing tracks, “Anointed” and “These Arms” make a good job at cleaning up the mess their predecessor makes.
Overall, ‘Leisure’ feels like an album where Miguel has been able to explore his capabilities as an artist. For the most part it is an inspired record that capitalizes on the singer’s background and talents. It has a few slips, a few skip-worthy moments that sadly hinder this from being a career-highlight project. Nevertheless, the highs on the tracklist as well as the unique, rare vocals from him, especially for a male artist, make it worth a listen.
Consequence of Sound - 54- Full Review:
The “fourth album curse”: fact or fiction? That is a question avid music listeners have pondered for years. Regardless of your take on the curse, what is true is that an artist’s fourth album is, more often than not, their most cardinal. They are past the initial rookie-jitters of searching for their sound and place in the musical landscape and have usually achieved a peak in commercial success. This makes their fourth studio album an important milestone in continuing to expand their artistic and commercial endeavors and strengthening their standing in the industry. On his fourth studio album, Leisure, Miguel, unfortunately, succumbs to this pressure, delivering a mundane, prosaic collection of music.
Coming in at a run time of nearly 45 minutes, Leisure should be a breeze of a record to get through. Yet, listening to it is a journey most tedious. “Sky Walker” is a perfect example of this, although there are several others on the record (“Anointed” being another main culprit”). The premier aforementioned track is riddled with an extremely monotone vocal delivery, from both Miguel and featured artist Jack Harlow. By the time the track ends, it feels more so as if you are sleepwalking. However, the album does not actually start out that dull. “Criminal”, featuring Lil Baby, kicks off the listen with a banging production, a quite distracting one at that. It completely overpowers Miguel’s performance, overshadowing the words he is singing (although that might just be a good thing with the song’s lyrics being extremely controversial, featuring him comparing the tragedy of 9/11 to heaven). You will remember this song, albeit not for the right reasons. The production of the record being a major aspect in bringing the record down is a common theme throughout the album. The following track, “Pineapple Skies”, had the potential to be great. It features some pretty well-written lyrics and is overall extremely chill, yet the production is missing a so-to-speak punch to really make the song great. The same can be said for “Wolf”, whose boring production does a disservice to the clever lyrics which incorporate direct dialogue from the childhood literature classic, Little Red Riding Hood.
It must be said though, that the production should not take full blame. The album’s songwriting is equally as guilty. At its root the writing is not terrible, the issue lies more in it being incomprehensible. Miguel is clearly a fan of stylistic elements, although he is not the best at them. One could return to “Sky Walker” for proof, but it is “Told You So”, the singer’s new single, which is the most egregious. Its lyrics are completely nonsensical. Miguel is singing to his presumed lover, but even that can not be confirmed. Between the verses, chorus, and bridge there is not one moment where the listener will be able to piece together what is being said, which is a shame, as sonically the song is a clear earworm inspired by Prince. Another area where Leisure’s writing struggles is its use of repetition. Now, repetition can be a beautiful thing lyrically if done well, Miguel himself shows this on the lead single “Come Through & Chill”, where the repetitiveness of the pre-chorus and chorus makes the song one of the catchiest hits of the year, however, it can also be pure laziness. “CPR” is an example of the former. With just 2 verses, the song is over 50 percent the chorus, which is an extremely elementary one. An added bridge could have brought flavor to the song, guiding it to something actually momentous.
Leisure is not all non-leisurely though. “Caramelo Duro” is an insanely fun song. The combination of an infectious production (with a wicked guitar riff) and addicting lyrics makes it the perfect choice as the next single. But it is “These Arms” which is the real masterclass we are used to receiving from Miguel. The singer provides us with an excellent vocal delivery, making the listener’s ears perk up after an album of near-ennui. The chorus’ melody is orgasmic, as Miguel serenades his lover. Acting as the album’s closer, it is a perfect fit, ensuring that at least one track is memorable.
For the entirety of Miguel’s new album, it is never quite clear what is going on. While the production and lyrics battle for the spotlight, it is the listener who ends up losing. Despite there being a sprinkle of highlights scattered across the 11-track record, the search to find them is not rather worth it. So does the fourth album curse exist? We still cannot be too sure, but Leisure is surely an addition to the evidence of proof that it does.
Re: Album Metacritic
Tue Aug 09, 2022 6:14 pm
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 8
Mixed: 2
Negative: 0
- Scores:
Variety - 85- Spoiler:
- Madison Beer has had a rough ride in the music industry. Bouncing around labels and dropping singles with no album for nearly nine years is surely enough to drive anyone crazy but Madison has managed to stay strong through it all and channel it into her fantastic debut album MADHOUSE. The songs themselves find her grappling with problems in her life and the world at large but the theme of perseverance remains throughout. The album starts off strong with ‘Fast Times’ and the lead single ‘Baby.’ Both are fun pop tracks that still carry the edge to them that runs through most of Madison’s music. On the fourth track, ‘Follow the White Rabbit,’ Madison’s vocals are laced with a hollow distortion that is seen on a lot of the tracks later on. It’s a very striking and effective way to carry the Madhouse aesthetic throughout the songs without explicitly having lyrics about it. The next song titled ‘XS’ is about consumerism. The track carries a good message and is a fun listen but the choice to feature the rapper CL is a curious one. The only other collab on this album is the album’s second single ‘Bitches These Days’ with Addison Rae. It discusses the two faced nature girls can have and how it would be better to be direct than fake. The two girls have had a tumultuous relationship in the media this past year and although it’s not clear when this song was recorded, you can’t help but feel they’re singing at each other. The tone abruptly shifts after this to ‘Reckless’ which is a slow, haunting song about a cheating partner. The intro is reminiscent of a child’s lullaby and the lyrics are framed as her reading is a storybook. Both of these work immensely well to give the narrator an innocence and vulnerability that hasn’t shown up much on this album. The next two songs seem to carry on the narrative set up by ‘Reckless’ as ‘Stay Numb And Carry On’ finds her managing her emotions and ‘Stole My Man’ is a jubilant song about how she’s glad the break up happened because she’s better for it. The latter is a joy to listen to and a clear single choice for the future. The album closes with ‘Sour Times’ which serves to bookend the album with a title mimicking the first track and shows how her attitude has changed during her journey through the “MADHOUSE.” Overall, the album is a very strong pop album that sticks out amongst it’s competitions and one that was well worth the almost decade long wait.
85
79
Rolling Stone - 74- Spoiler:
- Madison Beer releases her debut album madhouse. The fourteen track album dwelves on heartbreak and the emotional baggage that relationships can leave on us. On her debut she shows strongly who her musical influences are and gives us raw and honest lyrics when we get to the real deep cuts in the album. From catchy hooks to emotional lyrics Madison Beer’s Madhouse is a very solid debut. On “Fast Times” which fits perfectly as an opener, she sings about how fast tracked the relationship was, skipping stages and whether or not they meant it. Bass line and drums start the song and it quickly begins to add more to its production and feels fast paced, just like the relationship the song is talking about. Second track and lead single “Baby” feels very much like the hit single written for the album. While the song is catchy it feels artificial, despite the lyrics being about being too good for someone. The song's outro feels like an Ariana Grande redux and while Madison makes it work it feels just like a copycat version of an Ariana run rather than making it her own. The third track of the album “Don’t Say It” feels much more like a fully realized song than baby does. Madison proves she’s capable of catchy hooks, fun lyrics and great production. The bass on the song is a scene stealer and the way it's placed in the chorus just elevates the song. Madison doesn’t waste a single second in the song, lyrics get straight to the point. Rock and Matrix inspired “Follow the White Rabbit” is another song where Madison puts all her talents and creates a great song, probably the one that follows the madhouse theme the most. Random lyrics and guitar riffs make the song stand out the most. “XS” features CL, stands out among the album tracks a lot but mostly because it feels like an outlier on the project. A song that comments on how much rich people can spend, wanting more and not caring about its price, feels mostly out of place on a project dealing with heartbreak. “Stained Glass” a song about emotional baggage where Madison pours her heart out on how she feels with the things she’s been through. The simple production accompanies one of the lyrical stand outs on the album where’s willing to open her heart but still weary of being hurt. There’s an interlude on the album that goes directly to “Boyshit” another song that feels written to be a single with a catchy hook and artificial sounds. She calls out how the wrong things her partner says are not understandable due to her not being able to understand the bullshit that comes out of a man's mouth but despite the fun lyrical content its just not the best track on the album. It transitions pretty perfectly into “Why Do You Love Me?” which expands on the toxicity of the relationship she’s singing about, the instrumental compliments the way her vocals are layered. Second single “Bitches These Days” which features Addison Rae. A throwback pop punk song, whose lyrical content has Halsey up in arms. Is a fun track whose energy matches both Addison and Madison whose animosity, before this collaboration, makes the track all but better. “Reckless” is a track where Madison finally lets her songwriting free where she tells her feelings on her boyfriend cheating on her. A truly sincere track where she gets to unwind about the relationship, fake promises and friends being right. “Stay Numb and Carry On” a track where she sings about being numb and not being able to feel though it feels more on the side of getting over it and realizing that the relationship was never in a point of love. The drums accompany her message which transitions to “Stole My Man” where Madison realizes that she’s grateful for the girl that her ex cheated on with because she’s not with him anymore, and another great moment where the bass compliments the chorus extremely well. Madison leaves the album with “Sour Times” where she sings that a one night stand cant be more than that. The drums that can be heard in the background are the scene stealers on this track and Madison’s lyrics are left at a nice spot. Madhouse is a mostly sonically coherent debut album where Madison gets to tell her story, and while there’s always room for improvement she’s stepping in the right direction when it comes to her sound and lyrics.
71
71
70
68
58
50
Re: Album Metacritic
Mon Aug 29, 2022 2:24 pm
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 5
Mixed: 2
Negative: 1
- Scores:
75
73
72
65
62
57
56
30
Re: Album Metacritic
Wed Aug 31, 2022 8:20 pm
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 4
Mixed: 3
Negative: 0
- Scores:
90
79
78
64
60
56
52
Re: Album Metacritic
Fri Sep 02, 2022 6:37 pm
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 9
Mixed: 0
Negative: 0
- Scores:
85
83
78
75
71
70
70
69
65
Re: Album Metacritic
Mon Sep 05, 2022 6:05 pm
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 8
Mixed: 0
Negative: 0
- Scores:
90
87
81
75
75
67
63
58
Re: Album Metacritic
Thu Sep 08, 2022 3:36 pm
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 5
Mixed: 1
Negative: 1
- Scores:
92
86
77
72
66
53
30
Re: Album Metacritic
Sat Sep 10, 2022 3:27 pm
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 3
Mixed: 4
Negative: 0
- Scores:
100
82
74
60
58
56
47
Re: Album Metacritic
Tue Sep 13, 2022 3:25 pm
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 6
Mixed: 1
Negative: 0
- Scores:
77
73
70
69
68
66
40
Re: Album Metacritic
Thu Sep 15, 2022 10:30 am
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 7
Mixed: 0
Negative: 0
- Scores:
88
81
78
76
74
70
68
Re: Album Metacritic
Thu Sep 15, 2022 3:45 pm
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 7
Mixed: 0
Negative: 0
- Scores:
100
95
93
85
85
80
64
Re: Album Metacritic
Tue Sep 20, 2022 3:12 pm
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 5
Mixed: 0
Negative: 0
- Scores:
85
81
75
72
72
Re: Album Metacritic
Tue Sep 20, 2022 3:17 pm
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 4
Mixed: 3
Negative: 0
- Scores:
88
72
70
61
57
48
45
Re: Album Metacritic
Mon Sep 26, 2022 3:43 pm
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 5
Mixed: 0
Negative: 2
- Scores:
87
85
77
63
61
31
30
Re: Album Metacritic
Wed Sep 28, 2022 4:28 pm
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 7
Mixed: 0
Negative: 0
- Scores:
98
87
72
70
70
67
65
Re: Album Metacritic
Wed Oct 05, 2022 10:11 am
CRITIC REVIEWS BREAKDOWN
Positive: 6
Mixed: 0
Negative: 0
- Scores:
85
75
72
70
65
53
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum